I Was Once Transgender.
Why I Think Trump Made
the Right Decision for
the Military.

President Donald Trump announced on Wednesday that transgender individuals would not be permitted to serve in the military. (Photo: Carlo Allegri/Reuters/Newscom)
Our goal is to have intelligent discussion of the topics of the day. We realize everyone has their opinion and they should be allowed to express it in a discussion forum without calling each other names. We learn from discussion and not from name calling or argument.We use cookies to personalise content and ads, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. We also share information about your use of our site with our social media, advertising and analytics partners. See details

Donald Trump tweeted that he
wouldn’t allow transgender
individuals to serve in the
military:
decision—and as someone
who lived as trans-female for
several years, I should know.
voted earlier this month to not
block funding for transgender-
related hormone therapies and
sex change surgeries, I
wondered if it considered how
devastating this will be to the
fitness, readiness, and morale
of our combat-ready troops.
Representatives voted down
Missouri Republican Rep.
Vicky Hartzler’s amendment
to the National Defense
Authorization Act, which would
have banned the military from
funding such treatments.
surgeries for military service
members and their families
is beyond comprehensible.
that our military was forged to
be the world’s strongest
fighting force, not a government-
funded, politically correct,
medical sex change clinic
for people with gender
dysphoria.
diagnosis for one who feels at
odds with his or her birth gender,
develops from prolonged
anxiety and depression.
People are not born that way.
gender dysphoria is having
strongly held feelings—but
feelings can and often do
change over time.
prepare its members in warfare:
to kill, destroy, and break our
enemies. The most important
factors in preparing a strong
military are not hormone therapy,
surgical sex changes, or
politically correct education.
emotionally sound, highly
trained troops to protect our
nation from its enemies.
are currently sleeping under
cardboard boxes, or waiting
for life-saving care from the
Department of Veterans Affairs,
we learn that transgender
military recruits now qualify
for preferential coverage for sex
change procedures that are
scientifically unproven and
extremely costly.
reassigned from male to
female, and eventually came
to accept my birth gender.
life experience, eight years of
living as a woman, 20 years of
researching the topic, and 12
years of helping others who,
like me, found that transitioning
and reassignment surgery failed
to be proper treatment and want
to restore their lives to their birth
gender.
up to $130,000 per person for
numerous body-mutilating and
cosmetic procedures over many
months (or years) to fashion the
body to appear as the opposite
sex.
surgeon, or how much money
is spent, it is biologically
impossible to change a man
into a woman or a woman into
a man. The change is only
cosmetic.
continues to recommend this
radical “treatment” in the
absence of scientific evidence
that people are better off in the
long run. This population
attempts suicide at a rate
of 40 percent.
change, they attempt to end
their lives, or tragically succeed.
population suffer from
co-existing mental disorders.
Consider Bradley Manning
(now Chelsea Manning), a
former Army soldier who was
so psychologically and
emotionally unbalanced that
he stole confidential documents
from the military and forwarded
them to WikiLeaks.
Force, Not a Gender Clinic
sex change surgery.
sexchangeregret.com, I hear
from people who experienced
firsthand how damaging and
unnecessary reassignment
surgeries were. For them, the
sex change failed to resolve the
emotional and psychological
disorders that drove the desire to
change gender.
transgender life for years. They
write to ask for advice on how
to reverse the original surgical
change and restore their lives
to the original birth gender like
I did, a process called
detransition.
come to regret having
undergone the surgery and
will want to detransition. Where
will the military be then? Will
the military pay for the sex
change reversal procedure,
too?
are not uncommon and will
drive up the cost to care for
the military transgender
population above the
projected $3-4 billion 10-year
cost.
there’s the question of the
service member’s military
readiness during their
transition or detransition, as
the process often comes with
a great deal of anxiety and
emotional instability.
adapt to the new gender role for years
after reassignment surgery.
who works every day with regretters,
allowing the military to pay for sex
change surgeries will make a mockery
of the U.S. military.
of making others, via the government
and insurance companies, cover the
cost of sex change procedures.
the advocates would have used this
as leverage to press every other entity—
both government and commercial—to
pay for sex change surgeries as well.
life for eight years, I can attest that
assisting, affirming, or paying for
hormone therapies and genital mutilation
surgeries would not have strengthened
our military. They would only have
brought adverse long-term consequences,
both for individuals and for our armed
forces as a whole.