Yesterday, the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals said that religion cannot be used as a shield against ObamaCrapCare, that a religious organization must be forced to provide insurance for services for which that body does not support. They as well as the Supreme Court keep relying on the Commerce Clause to force all employers to purchase a product, in this case health insurance. We disagree strongly, however, do not feel that we will win as Roberts has been turned into a stool pigeon or even worse, a sell out to his supposedly conservative beliefs.
This is a continuation of a sad story in American history. The law is being twisted into something that the Founders would not recognize. On top of it being a terribly written and conceived law, it is patently illegal to force someone to purchase anything. What is next-- you must own a car from Government Motors or you must have solar panels on your house or you must employ illegal aliens or you must ... (you fill in the blank)?
Once you require that a free man must purchase a product, he no longer is free. He is a subject to whomever sells that product. Prices can be raised arbitrarily and you must pay the fare.
In the case of ObamaCrapCare, supposedly prices can only go up so far each year, however, who says that "waivers" would not be granted for larger increases due to a health crisis or as a favor for a company that provided money to a campaign--but that would not happen, right?
On the price topic, we heard today (from one of our companies for which we sell health insurance) that prices for insurance in Ohio were going up a tiny 98% effective January 1st. So much for the argument that rates would be stable!!
We must end ObamaCrapCare, it is a disaster and it will only get worse.
Conservative Tom
Federal Court Rejects Christian University’s Request To Overturn Obamacare, Opens Possibility Of New SCOTUS Consideration
July 12, 2013 by Sam Rolley
On Thursday, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Commerce Clause of the Constitution’s gives Congress the authority to demand that employers purchase private health insurance for their employees or pay government fines.
By rejecting the Liberty University lawsuit that was a bid to overturn the healthcare law on grounds of religious freedom, the court opened up the possibility that the Supreme Court could once again hear arguments about Obamacare, as the university plans to appeal.
“Plaintiffs present no plausible claim that the act substantially burdens their free exercise of religion, by forcing them to facilitate or support abortion or otherwise,” Judge James A. Wynn Jr. wrote in the opinion. He wrote the law “allows an individual to obtain, and an employer to offer, a plan that covers no abortion services at all.”
Liberty attorney Mat Staver said the fight isn’t over.
“At least the court reached the merits and did not try to dodge the issues on procedural or standing grounds,” he said. “This clears the way to go to the U.S. Supreme Court, which will be the final stop anyway.”