Contact Form

Name

Email *

Message *

Showing posts with label shtetl. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shtetl. Show all posts

Thursday, March 27, 2014

Is It Crazy To Release Terrorists? Should Israel Do So To Get Peace? We Don't Think So.

Israel as a 'crazy state': A new definition for political science?

No government on this earth has any legal right to free terrorists as a “gesture for peace.”

Benjamin Netanyahu attends the weekly cabinet meeting at his office in Jerusalem March 23, 2014. 
(Photo by: REUTERS)
When I was still a young political science professor, back in the 1970s, the term “crazy state” was used sparingly in the lexicon of academic nuclear strategy. More precisely, it was referenced in assorted learned discussions of countries that may sometime be controlled by irrational national leaders, and could therefore depart from usual rules of mutual deterrence. The potential consequence of any such departure, we had already understood, could have included nuclear aggression, or perhaps even nuclear war.
A ready example, back then, would have been a nuclear Iraq (remember Saddam Hussein and Osirak?).
Today, I am prepared to advance an altogether different but equally useful meaning of “crazy state.” This definition is any country, but in particular, one that is half the size of America's Lake Michigan, and beleaguered by determinedly existential foes that would willfully trade its terrorist prisoners for presumed enemy “good will.” Even crazier, of course, is any such country that had already made this self-destructive set of concessions several times in the past, always with a conspicuous lack of success, and always with the result of eliciting more terrorism.
Soon, Israel could become this new sort of “crazy state.” Indeed, by the end of this month, Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu is expected to free more Palestinian terrorists in the latest “round” of formally negotiated releases. Once again, many of those killers scheduled to be released had been directly involved with the burning, maiming, torturing and murder of Israeli noncombatants. Absolutely no one questions this heinous criminal involvement, least of all, the perpetrators.
In Jewish literature, any such impending terrorist release would at first seem to flow in part from the genre of the Wise Men of Chelm, long-cherished tales that celebrate the misadventures of recognizably hapless fools, lovable nitwits who inhabit a legendary shtetl.
But this latest political deal is hardly a comedic matter. True enough, the Israel that would be left in the wake of encroaching Palestinian statehood – isolated, fragmented, and vulnerable – could quickly come to resemble authentic shtetls. At the same time, this newly-residual Jewish community, marginalized by its own glaring lack of judgment and sense of decency, would be utterly lacking in humor.
There are also pertinent legal issues involved in any still-planned terrorist releases, egregious violations of “higher law” principles that would necessarily override those particular agreements fashioned between the so-called Palestinian Authority and Israel. Why “so-called?” On January 3, 2013, Palestinian Authority leader Mahmoud Abbas “decreed” the absorption of the “former PA” into the “State of Palestine.” This decree eliminated the PA, yet did not legally create a successor state.
To properly meet the criteria of sovereignty under international law, “Palestine” would have had to be more than self-declared. Specifically, it would have had to fulfill listed expectations of the Convention on the Rights and Duties of States (1934). This governing treaty on statehood is also sometimes known as the Montevideo Convention.
All countries coexist under a binding law of nations. A core element of this international law is the unambiguously sacred rule of Nullum crimen sine poena, or “No crime without a punishment.” An unchanging principle, drawn, significantly, from the law of Ancient Israel, it was reaffirmed for all nations at the precedent-setting Nuremberg Trials (1945-46).
To the extent that the president of the United States should concur in the upcoming Israeli terrorist release – and this extent, of course, is total – the US will also be in violation of international law. And it will be in opposition to the domestic law of the United States. International law is an integral part of US law, inter alia, by virtue of Article 6 of the US Constitution, the “Supremacy Clause,” and of a number of US Supreme Court decisions, most notably, The Paquete Habana (1900).
Every state has an unerring obligation under international law to apprehend and punish terrorists. This duty derives, in part, from the vital expectation, “No crime without a punishment.” It is codified widely and separately, but is also deducible from the authoritative Nuremberg Principles (1950). These fundamental rules emerged from the previously mentioned Nuremberg Trials.
Terrorism is more than just bad behavior. It represents a major crime under international law. In the past, some of the Palestinian terrorists released in “good will gestures” were also guilty of crimes of war and crimes against humanity. These Nuremberg-category crimes are so serious that the perpetrators are known in jurisprudence as Hostes humani generis, or “Common enemies of humankind.”  
Always, international law presumes solidarity between individual states in the obligatory fight against terrorism. Israel has incontestable jurisdiction to punish crimes committed on its own territory; on occasion, it may also have the right to act under certain broader principles of “universal jurisdiction.” Its particular case for any such wider jurisdiction can be found, among other places, at the four Geneva Conventions of August 12, 1949.
No government on this earth has any legal right to free terrorists as a “goodwill gesture,” or as a “gesture for peace.” Terrorism is a criminally sanctionable violation of international law, a wrong that is never subject to any sanitizing manipulations by individual countries, however well-intentioned. In the United States, the president's power to pardon purposefully excludes any violations of international law.
In its original capture and punishment of Palestinian terrorists, Israel had effectively acted on behalf of all nations. Because some of these terrorists had also committed crimes directed against other states, Israel cannot now permissibly pardon these offenses contra other sovereigns. Although Prime Minister Netanyahu's next terrorist release would not, strictly speaking, represent a genuine “pardon,” it would still have the identical legal effect.
Under international law, Prime Minister Netanyahu's planned end-of-month release of Palestinian terrorists, essentially analogous to a mass pardoning of international criminals, would implicate the Jewish state for a “denial of justice.” This could have distinctly injurious new consequences. For one, any such Israeli freeing of terrorists would further undermine the Jewish state's binding legal obligation to incapacitate violent criminals from committing additional acts of barbarism and mass murder.
Will Netanyahu continue with inexcusable Israeli violations of law and justice by releasing still more Arab terrorists? If he does, his country will then fully deserve to be called a “crazy state.”
Louis René Beres was educated at Princeton (Ph.D., 1971), and is Professor of Political Science and International Law at Purdue University. He is the author of ten major books, and several hundred scholarly articles, dealing with terrorism, war, and international law. His popular essays and opinion columns have been featured in The Atlantic, The Jerusalem Post, The New York Times, Christian Science Monitor, Los Angeles Times, US News & World Report, The Washington Post, Ha'aretz and Israel National News. Dr. Beres was born in Zürich, Switzerland, at the end of World War II.

Wednesday, February 12, 2014

Jews Need To Wake Up To The Existential Threat Against Israel. Time Is Of The Essence.


Share This Post
 25
http://israel-commentary.org/?p=8525
Redacted from an article by Gil Solomon
February 10, 2014
I could not have been more disgusted when hearing about a recent prayer rally organized by thousands of orthodox Jews at the Kotel (Western Wall), the aim of which was to beseech the almighty to “cancel the decrees” of the US Secretary of State. Cancel the “decrees”! Do they regard Kerry as an Emperor who issues decrees from on high for which they, as poor ghetto Jews, have no power over whatsoever? This act of cringing passivity only reinforces the view that these people do not regard Israel as a sovereign nation in control of its own destiny.
The way Israel is behaving one could easily come to this conclusion but to the main issue, if a rally is organized it should be to beseech G-d to put some sense and a spine into the current Israeli leadership and once the prayers are over to move on and:
1. Demand that the sovereign nation of Israel finally gets up off its knees and cease its relentless capitulation to Kerry’s demands.
2. Demand that the true story of the nation be told whereby the so called “Palestinian” narrative be exposed as the fiction that it is.
It is my opinion that Obama and Kerry aim to destroy Israel or at least bring it to its knees. The 2003 Bush Road Map was in theory a blueprint of where these so called “negotiations” could revolve, but Obama and Kerry have deviated so far off course as to make this “roadmap” a dirt track in the middle of nowhere. This is the track they want Israel to travel on and to date Israel has foolishly indulged their every whim, including the release of the most heinous terrorist murderers in order to just bring Abbas to the table. It should be of great significance that Obama has put Muslim Brotherhood members/sympathizers in key administrative positions in his administration.
The current US administration, headed by someone whose credentials for office are dubious, is a clear and present danger to the Jewish nation, yet American Jews, by a vast majority and to their shame have voted for Obama not once but twice!
All the warning signs were there for those whose eyes were open and were not deaf. Now we have the disgraceful recent spectacle of a brainwashed American Jewry, a group truly worthy of the title of ghetto Jews of the diaspora, attacking the New York City (NYC) Mayor, Bill de Blasio for his support of Israel!
(The author neglects to mention the vaunted American Jewish political lobby AIPAC (American Israel Political Affairs Committee) that recently genuflected, capitulating to Obama/Kerry and pouring cold water in the faces of the dedicated 42 Republican Congressmen that demanded sanctions continue and in the process AIPAC also spat in the faces of PM Netanyahu and the state of Israel that knows these sanctions are the only weapons remotely successful in slowing down Iran’s nuclear arsenal. Someone at AIPAC evidently forgot that supporting Israel is supposedly AIPAC’s main raison d’être ) jsk
Israel’s own paralysis is the net result of being sucked into the Obama so called “peace process”. Combined with the constant lack of support and hostility towards Israel and what it stands for has led to an IDF that has lost the confidence or will to even deal with a rag tag bunch of rock throwers on the West Bank. The IDF is taunted daily but refuses to respond in the only way that these people will understand. No other army on the face of the earth would put up with this nonsense.
Worse still, according to Israel’s Chief of Military Intelligence, Major General Aviv Kohavi, Israel faces 170,000 rockets aimed at her. To quote General Kohavi: “Israel is surrounded by 360 degrees of actual enemies. We call this period in time the ‘Era of Fire,’ in light of the amount of missiles and rockets we face as a constant threat. There are about 170,000 rockets and missiles that threaten Israel. For the first time the enemy now has the ability to hit Israeli cities hard. IAF pilots can no longer move freely towards their targets and have to dodge missiles that threaten them.”
MK Tzipi Livni, is the disaster of a “negotiator” — a woman totally out of her depth but who unbelievably heads the so called “peace talks” on behalf of Israel is a prime example of a left winger hell bent on capitulation. A woman who has no concept of the fact that capitulation after capitulation brings more and more outrageous demands.
Not lost too are Kerry’s stupid hints that, should the peace process fail, the intifada will resume. One has to assume that Abbas is not a fool. He would have realized that he has just been given the green light by a US Secretary of State to restart a massive terrorist campaign when these talks break down. Peace to Abbas would mean obscurity and this man, together with the rest of the PA will not give up their lavish lifestyles which includes them being feted by world leaders on centre stage and indulging themselves with money that is bestowed on them by foolish nations who think they are aiding the cause of peace and the supposed suffering of a people who have attempted to rewrite history.
The Israelis, for some inexplicable reason, fail to present the irrefutable history that in biblical times, all of what is now Israel and Judea and Samaria (West Bank) was Jewish. When the Romans conquered the territory they named the entire area “Philistina” in order to rub salt into the wounds of the defeated Jews by renaming it in honour of the Jews’ ancient and mortal enemies the Philistines. Decades later, Arabs cleverly commandeered the term “Palestinian” as their own designation when for all the centuries before they were just Arabs who happened to be living on what was historically Israeli land.
No other country or people on the face of the earth would have even indulged their ludicrous and incessant claims nor given them the time of day. Unfortunately for Israel, it to this day has no concept of Hasbara (public relations), let alone realizes that Hasbara is a war that Abbas and Co. have mastered to an extent beyond their wildest imagination. They have turned history on its head and convinced the world of the truth of the Palestinian narrative.
It is now up to supporters of Israel and finally the Israelis to counter this gross lie and get Israel off the defensive and unleash the great power that G-d has once more given the Jews to insure their survival.
(Gil Solomon is a retired finance manager and author.)
- See more at: http://israel-commentary.org/?p=8525#sthash.iZSirNsu.dpuf