The Anti-Science Mainstreaming of Mental Illness
JANUARY 4, 2017
On Tuesday, the U.K.'s Daily Mail reported that 23-year-old Anna Teshu of
Staten Island, New York, has gone missing. Teshu's 15 minutes of fame began
in 2015 when she was featured on the internet because her boyfriend was
walking her around on a leash in public. Her boyfriend said: "The collar is like
a ring for most couples. They use rings, we have a collar." Teshu reportedly
enjoyed spending time in a puppy cage, as well. She explained, "The first time
I put on a collar I thought, 'Now I need to find someone for the other end.'"
Staten Island, New York, has gone missing. Teshu's 15 minutes of fame began
in 2015 when she was featured on the internet because her boyfriend was
walking her around on a leash in public. Her boyfriend said: "The collar is like
a ring for most couples. They use rings, we have a collar." Teshu reportedly
enjoyed spending time in a puppy cage, as well. She explained, "The first time
I put on a collar I thought, 'Now I need to find someone for the other end.'"
That same year, she was arrested for animal cruelty after allegedly leaving a
dog in a hot car. Her attorney said, "She's a disabled person." She was found
mentally unfit to stand trial and escaped conviction. Now she is missing.
dog in a hot car. Her attorney said, "She's a disabled person." She was found
mentally unfit to stand trial and escaped conviction. Now she is missing.
All of this makes headlines because the media and the public decided to treat
a mentally ill person as a mentally healthy person making "alternative choices."
Instead of Teshu receiving the help she so obviously needed, the media chose
to treat her as a unique flower blooming, and the public nodded along in order
to appear tolerant -- all the while laughing.
a mentally ill person as a mentally healthy person making "alternative choices."
Instead of Teshu receiving the help she so obviously needed, the media chose
to treat her as a unique flower blooming, and the public nodded along in order
to appear tolerant -- all the while laughing.
Teshu isn't alone.
In 2015, Sarah Boesveld of the National Post in Canada reported on a new
phenomenon: "transabled" people, who feel that they've been born disabled
people in healthy bodies. Some of these people cut off their own limbs.
According to Boesveld: "Most crave an amputation or paralysis, though
(one researcher) has interviewed one person wants his penis removed.
Another wants to be blind. Many people ... arrange 'accidents' to help
achieve the goal." According to the researcher, "this disorder is starting to
be thought of as a neurological problem with the body's mapping, rather
than a mental illness."
phenomenon: "transabled" people, who feel that they've been born disabled
people in healthy bodies. Some of these people cut off their own limbs.
According to Boesveld: "Most crave an amputation or paralysis, though
(one researcher) has interviewed one person wants his penis removed.
Another wants to be blind. Many people ... arrange 'accidents' to help
achieve the goal." According to the researcher, "this disorder is starting to
be thought of as a neurological problem with the body's mapping, rather
than a mental illness."
While Teshu and the transabled may seem fringe, transgenderism is quickly
becoming mainstream. Media advocates for transgenderism as mental
health say that men who believe they are women, for example, are actually
women and ought to be treated as such, insisting that members of society
refer to them using female pronouns. In December, the 6th U.S. Circuit
Court of Appeals determined that an Ohio school district must let a young
girl continue to use the restroom of her choice, stating that to prevent it
would "further confuse a young girl with special needs ... and subject her
to further irreparable harm." The young girl in question is a boy who believes
she is a girl.
becoming mainstream. Media advocates for transgenderism as mental
health say that men who believe they are women, for example, are actually
women and ought to be treated as such, insisting that members of society
refer to them using female pronouns. In December, the 6th U.S. Circuit
Court of Appeals determined that an Ohio school district must let a young
girl continue to use the restroom of her choice, stating that to prevent it
would "further confuse a young girl with special needs ... and subject her
to further irreparable harm." The young girl in question is a boy who believes
she is a girl.
None of this is an argument for governmental intervention. It is an argument
for society to stop treating mental illness as mental health -- for the good
of the mentally ill. Delusions should not be treated as reality. And treatments
that do not work (transgender surgery has no impact on suicide rate,
for example) should not be treated as solutions, particularly when those
treatments are applied to children.
for society to stop treating mental illness as mental health -- for the good
of the mentally ill. Delusions should not be treated as reality. And treatments
that do not work (transgender surgery has no impact on suicide rate,
for example) should not be treated as solutions, particularly when those
treatments are applied to children.
That does not mean that good solutions have been found for many of
these mental illnesses. But to stop searching for good solutions and
deem the problem solved by virtue of instilling the normalcy of the
illness is counterproductive and dangerous.
these mental illnesses. But to stop searching for good solutions and
deem the problem solved by virtue of instilling the normalcy of the
illness is counterproductive and dangerous.
My grandfather was hospitalized for paranoid schizophrenia in the
960s. He thought he heard the radio talking to him. Today's society would
presumably determine that a lifestyle choice and celebrate his diversity
rather than getting him the lithium treatment he required, which saved his
family. A society that thinks itself kind while treating mental illness as
"letting your freak flag fly" and all the while silently snickering at the
supposed freaks is a cruel society indeed.
960s. He thought he heard the radio talking to him. Today's society would
presumably determine that a lifestyle choice and celebrate his diversity
rather than getting him the lithium treatment he required, which saved his
family. A society that thinks itself kind while treating mental illness as
"letting your freak flag fly" and all the while silently snickering at the
supposed freaks is a cruel society indeed.
COPYRIGHT CREATORS 2017
